Earlier this week, I was watching television and I happened to notice a striking similarity in three different automobile advertisements. The ads were for full or mid-sized luxury cars and each one was touting fuel efficiency as a unique selling proposition.
Buick LaCrosse commercial with Shaquille O'Neal was one of them.
Although my memory has failed me, I'm fairly certain one was a
However, the individual car brands are not as important as the focus
automobile manufacturers are putting on fuel economy again, as fuel
prices steadily rise.
But will car buyers buy what they're selling? They're a couple of problems with their strategies.
First of all, using fuel efficiency as a unique selling point is
decidedly less effective when everyone does it. It was three different
car companies in the span of one night that tried to sell me on the fact
that their car was going to save me money at the pump. But with
everyone using the same selling point, the brands get confused and I
only end up remembering one of the ads.
Interestingly, I can recall that a Toyota Prius is fuel efficient car
though. The reason for this is that the only point Prius every drives
home in their ads is that the car is fuel efficient- not stylish, fast,
luxurious, or even safe. They own MPG and everything a Prius does tries
to improve our associations with Prius and saves on fuel. A Prius is
only a small car; there isn't a Prius compact, a Prius midsized and a
Prius SUV. Thus, it makes sense to the customer that a Prius will get
good fuel economy.
Another reason these other brands are getting lost in the noise is
because their trying to communicate too much. The car is luxurious and
it's fuel efficient. The idea that a big power-packed luxury car gets
good fuel economy contradicts what most people believe to be true.
It's not by mistake that Toyota hasn't made a truly stylish Prius.
Interestingly, by not being stylish and luxurious, the association we
make to the Prius and it's fuel economy is amplified.
It's the same scenario as diet soda versus regular soda - the ideas
contradict in our minds and therefore product isn't consumed because it
has low calories and great taste - which explains why most people only drink one variety exclusively.
By not differentiating with one singular pitch, your brand risks
rendering the entire message useless because it will wind up lost in the
clutter or greeted with disbelief.
This post also appeared on Talent Zoo's Beneath the Brand blog.